Environments of Indifference: Architecture and Algorithmic Governmentality

Spencer, D. 2017. Environments of Indifference: Architecture and Algorithmic Governmentality. Architecture, Natures and Data: The Politics of Environments. Tallinn, Estonia 20 - 22 Apr 2017

TitleEnvironments of Indifference: Architecture and Algorithmic Governmentality
AuthorsSpencer, D.
TypeConference keynote
Abstract

If the environment is now defined in terms of data, logistics and computation, as an automated ‘algorithmic governmentality’ that encircles and enfolds us, then how might we understand its relationship to architecture? For much of the twentieth century architecture was progressively conceived as a medium through which the subject could be reconnected with its natural environment. For László Moholy-Nagy modernist architecture, with its spatial fluidity, its transparent and reflective surfaces, effects a new union with nature. For Buckminster Fuller, Reyner Banham and others, new materials and technologies enable architecture, and its users, to escape the literal and metaphorical weight of traditional building. Architecture’s new immanence to the environment is conceived in terms of liberation, facilitating nomadic and ecologically modelled lifestyles. The environment, understood as a complex of cybernetic and natural systems, is figured as opening on to new freedoms.

An almost diametrically opposed conception appears in more contemporary characterisations of the environment within other fields. For Michel Foucault it is power itself that now operates environmentally, succeeding sovereign and disciplinary regimes in which its locus could be more clearly identified. The environment is a field of discourses and practices played out according to the obscure rules of a neoliberal truth game. Antoinette Rouvroy’s concept of an ‘algorithmic governmentality’ further develops Foucault’s conception of power along these lines. Governance through automation, logistics and big data constitutes a ‘perceptual regime’ that sets the terms under which the ‘physical world and its inhabitants’ are rendered visible and intelligible. Whereas the subject’s experience of the environment remains centre stage within architectural discourse, it is marginal to the concerns of this regime. Algorithmic governmentality is largely indifferent to the subject. It does not need to tame behaviour or produce docile beings. In fact, she argues, it ‘simply ignores embodied individuals’ since the only ‘subject’ its operations require is a ‘statistical body’. Algorithmic governmentality is, then, fundamentally calculative, indifferent to belief, and concerned only with the remote management of the behaviour of subjects for whom its operational procedures remain opaque. Its perceptual regime forecloses critique and shuts down the virtual horizons of the subject, containing it within a permanent condition of informatic processing.

Here, I will explore the part played by architecture within the perceptual regime described by Rouvroy. Focusing in particular on contemporary transit systems, I will explore the ways in which their swarm-modelled design and planning is premised on precisely the kind of indifferent, pre-conscious and behaviouristic conception of the subject to which Rouvroy refers in her critique. Turning then to the architectural treatment of these spaces, I will analyse how, through their cladding, styling and ornament, these work to acculturate us to the indifference to which we are now subject, to the closing down of horizons, to the acceptance of our marginalisation within systems whose logic must necessarily, it is made to appear, remain opaque to our own cognitive capacities.

KeywordsArchitecture, Neoliberalism, Governmentality, Logistics, Affect Theory, Data
Year2017
ConferenceArchitecture, Natures and Data: The Politics of Environments
Web address (URL)http://architecturesnaturesdata.com

Related outputs

Agency and Artifice in the Environment of Neoliberalism
Spencer, D. 2018. Agency and Artifice in the Environment of Neoliberalism. in: Waterman, T. and Wall, E. (ed.) Landscape and Agency: Critical Essays London and New York Routledge.

Material and Rational Feminisms: A contribution to humane architectures
Spencer, D. and Rawes, P. 2017. Material and Rational Feminisms: A contribution to humane architectures. in: Frichot, H., Gabrielsson, C. and Runting, H. (ed.) Architecture and Feminisms Ecologies, Economies, Technologies London Routledge. pp. 153-162

Space After Spectacle
Spencer, D. 2017. Space After Spectacle. Architecture, Phantasmagoria and the Culture of Contemporary Capitalism. Georgia Tech, Atlanta, GA 31 - 31 Mar 2017

Dumb Abstraction: Semper, Kracauer, and the Superficial Materialism of Architecture
Spencer, D. 2017. Dumb Abstraction: Semper, Kracauer, and the Superficial Materialism of Architecture . Praznine. 1 (10), pp. 23-30.

Requiem for a Dreamworld
Spencer, D. 2016. Requiem for a Dreamworld . The (Dis)enchanted Subject of Architecture: Between Neoliberalism and Neobaroque. Architectural Association, London 25 - 25 Nov 2016

Material and Rational Feminisms
Spencer, D. and Rawes, P. 2016. Material and Rational Feminisms. Architecture and Feminisms: 13th International AHRA Conference. KTH, Stockholm, Sweden 17 - 19 Nov 2016

Immediate Affect: Architecture, Neoliberalism and the Patterning of Experience
Spencer, D. 2016. Immediate Affect: Architecture, Neoliberalism and the Patterning of Experience. The Architecture of Deregulations: Postmodernism, Politics and the Built Environment in Europe 1975-1995. KTH, Stockholm, Sweden 10 - 12 Mar 2016

Less than Enough: A Critique of Aureli
Spencer, D. 2016. Less than Enough: A Critique of Aureli. in: Stoppani, T., Ponzo, G. and Themistokleous, G. (ed.) This Thing Called Theory London and New York Routledge. pp. 283-291

Out of the Loop: Architecture, Automation and Cognitive Disinvestment
Spencer, D. 2016. Out of the Loop: Architecture, Automation and Cognitive Disinvestment. Volume #49: Hello World. 49, pp. 7-10.

The Limits of Limits: Schmitt, Aureli, and the Geopolitical Ontology of the Island
Spencer, D. 2016. The Limits of Limits: Schmitt, Aureli, and the Geopolitical Ontology of the Island. in: Daou, D. and Pérez-Ramos, P. (ed.) New Geographies 08: Island Cambridge, MA Harvard University: Graduate School of Design. pp. 118-127

The Architecture of Neoliberalism: How Architecture Became an Instrument of Control and Compliance
Spencer, D. 2016. The Architecture of Neoliberalism: How Architecture Became an Instrument of Control and Compliance. London Bloomsbury Academic.

Nature is the Dummy: Circulations of the Metabolic
Spencer, D. 2014. Nature is the Dummy: Circulations of the Metabolic. in: Ibanez, D and Katsikis, N (ed.) Grounding Metabolism: New Geographies 06 Harvard, MA Harvard University: Graduate School of Design. pp. 108-113

The Architecture of managerialism: OMA, CCTV, and the post-political
Spencer, D. 2014. The Architecture of managerialism: OMA, CCTV, and the post-political. in: Lahiji, N. (ed.) Architecture Against the Post-Political: Essays in Reclaiming the Critical Project London and New York Routledge. pp. 151-166

The New Phantasmagoria: Transcoding the Violence of Financial Capitalism
Spencer, D. 2014. The New Phantasmagoria: Transcoding the Violence of Financial Capitalism. in: Lahiji, N. (ed.) The Missed Encounter of Radical Philosophy with Architecture London, New Dehli, New York, Sydney Bloomsbury. pp. 79-94

Smooth operators: architectural Deleuzism in societies of control
Spencer, D. 2012. Smooth operators: architectural Deleuzism in societies of control. PhD thesis University of Westminster School of Architecture and the Built Environment https://doi.org/10.34737/8z93y

Permalink - https://westminsterresearch.westminster.ac.uk/item/q25x1/environments-of-indifference-architecture-and-algorithmic-governmentality


Share this

Usage statistics

180 total views
0 total downloads
These values cover views and downloads from WestminsterResearch and are for the period from September 2nd 2018, when this repository was created.