WestminsterResearch

Commensurability and beyond: from Mises and Neurath to the future of the socialist calculation debate

Greenwood, Dan (2006) Commensurability and beyond: from Mises and Neurath to the future of the socialist calculation debate. Economy and Society, 35 (1). pp. 65-90. ISSN 0308-5147

[img]
Preview
PDF
153Kb

Official URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/03085140500465857

Abstract

Mises' 'calculation argument' against socialism argues that monetary calculation is indispensable as a commensurable unit for evaluating factors of production. This is not due to his conception of rationality being purely 'algorithmic,' for it accommodates non-monetary, incommensurable values. Commensurability is needed, rather, as an aid in the face of economic complexity. The socialist Neurath's response to Mises is unsatisfactory in rejecting the need to explore possible non-market techniques for achieving a certain degree of commensurability. Yet Neurath's contribution is valuable in emphasizing the need for a balanced, comparative approach to the question of market versus non-market that puts the commensurability question in context. These central issues raised by adversaries in the early socialist calculation debate have continued relevance for the contemporary discussion.

Item Type:Article
Uncontrolled Keywords:Socialism, calculation, commensurability, money, rationality, value
Research Community:University of Westminster > Social Sciences, Humanities and Languages, School of
ID Code:4624
Deposited On:15 Jan 2008
Last Modified:11 Aug 2010 15:32

Repository Staff Only: item control page