Multi-method personality assessment of butchers and hunters: beliefs and reality

Voracek, Martin , Gabler, Daniela, Kreutzer, Carmen, Stieger, Stefan, Swami, Viren and Formann, Anton K. (2010) Multi-method personality assessment of butchers and hunters: beliefs and reality. Personality and Individual Differences, 49 (7). pp. 819-822. ISSN 0191-8869

Full text not available from this repository.
Official URL:


Two studies examined beliefs about the personality of male butchers and hunters and the factuality of such beliefs. These professions’ daily routines involve killing animals and handling their carcasses, acts that could be facilitated by specific personality constellations. Study 1 (102 raters) evidenced perceptions of higher aggressiveness and masculinity of butchers/hunters and higher self-esteem (hunters only), as compared with average men. In contrast, Study 2 found little evidence for the factuality of such beliefs, based on multi-method personality assessments in a case-control design of 96 men (23 and 25 dyads including one butcher or hunter, matched with same-generation, other-occupation friends or relatives). Only implicit, but not explicit, aggressiveness (measured with an Implicit Association Test) was higher in butchers/hunters than in controls. Both masculinity (whether measured unobtrusively [digit ratio, 2D:4D] or explicitly) and self-esteem (whether measured implicitly [name-letter effect] or explicitly) were comparable for butchers/hunters and controls. Lower self-reported conscientiousness, extraversion, and openness in butchers/hunters than controls were not generalizable to informant reports of these Big Five dimensions. Discussion focuses on the merits of utilizing belief-factuality contrasts, controlled designs, and multi-method assessments in personality research.

Item Type: Article
Subjects: University of Westminster > Social Sciences and Humanities
Depositing User: Miss Nina Watts
Date Deposited: 13 Sep 2011 15:40
Last Modified: 13 Sep 2011 15:40

Actions (login required)

Edit Item (Repository staff only) Edit Item (Repository staff only)